The Woman who Became a Walnut Tree

translation based on the interlinear of Oliver LaMère

Hocąk-English Interlinear Text


Once men had a town there. Then in the fall when the walnuts ripened, one woman ate a walnut and she liked it so much that when she was done she would not sell any of them. They went to the village there, but she would not come. And as she kept herself there her legs transformed into tree roots. When they tried to cut them away, they failed, and soon she became a great walnut tree. It is said that the woman became a tree.

The End1

Commentary. This appears to be a morality tale in which a woman becomes so inordinately fond of walnuts that she fails to share them even for a price. Thus her punishment for being obsessed in this way was to become the object of her obsession.

However, on closer examination we see that the punishment strangely fits the crime. The walnut tree hoards its fruits only up to the point at which it becomes ripe; then it is either harvested or falls to the ground. Thus the walnut tree never gets to keep the ripe and tasty nuts. So the woman who hoarded the nuts for their rich, ripe taste, now is a being that cannot retain the very thing that she most desires. She is now forced to give away the crop entirely with nothing left for herself — the exact opposite of her human behavior.


Yet, there may be a great deal more to it than this. Viewed from the standpoint of Hocąk symbolism, a rather different meaning is imputed to the story of an eating obsession. In the preliminaries to war, one of the rituals engaged in by a warparty before they go on the war road is the Fast Eating Contest. In this ritual, the premiss is that the eating of the meal, which is done as fast as possible, magically reflects what is to happen on the warpath. The food thus consumed is said to represent the souls of those who will be killed or captured in the upcoming fight, and any food left uneaten represents souls that have escaped. So in this context, eating represents the capture of a soul (living or departed). Therefore, swallowing is a form of capture. What is captured, we might ask, when one swallows a walnut? To answer this, we need to review the soul-symbolism attached to trees. Metaphorically, a person's descendants are said to be rejų́na, "roots." So, again metaphorically, if she has put out roots, then she has produced descendants. The roots extend from her legs, which in Hocąk is denoted by the word hu, which also means a plant's stem or stalk. So literally (in the story and in botany) the rejų́na extend from the hura. The two legs of a woman form a fork, in Hocąk, ca. This same word, as a homonym, is said to mean, "wife, friend," although Marino puts a question mark after this entry in her dictionary. Nevertheless, the connection is indeed made. In a work that has come down to us only in English, the Green Man is upset that someone has kidnapped his wife, but Big Bellied One admonishes him, saying, "Women are considered just so many forked sticks ... if you are that weak just pick another forked branch. ... I myself will go get a forked branch for you, as there is a whole forest of them out there. Don't do it [go after your wife], for it is a very shameful thing to have trouble over women." This homology brings us to the walnut itself. The stem ca- has an expanded form, cak, which also means "forked"; but in addition, it means "walnut." The walnut is therefore the forked tree par excellance. It is natural, therefore, that a woman who is a "forked branch" might become the "forked tree." So what is the nut in this scheme of metaphors? It is literally the seed of the tree, and her obsessive and exclusive consumption of it lead to her hura putting down rejų́na, or interpreted symbolically, giving birth. Yet it is from the seed that she gave birth. It is the physical seed that she took into her "mouth" (vagina), but the soul to which the allegory refers came from above. The taking in of the tree's seeds made her sprout roots, that is, descendants. Just as the name cak denotes bifurcation and therefore duality, the very nut which is the embryo is itself doubly dualistic. Like many nuts it is composed of two halves, but unlike many others, it has a husk and a shell, another duality. Hocąk marriage is between a man of one moiety and a woman of a complementary moiety. Someone from the Upper Moiety must marry a person from the Lower (or Earth) Moiety. The walnut drops from the sky, and lands on earth, where it grows in both directions. This fact by itself reflects the marriage of the Above with the Below, the two complementary moieties. That the embryonic plant is itself dualistic reinforces this analogy. Therefore, when she ate the dualistic cak, she captured a dualistic soul, the soul of a Ho-cak, made from the uniting of the Above with the Below.

Comparative Material. The Hocąk waiką is similar to the Greek story of Tantalus who stole the divine food, the ambrosia, and shared it among his mortal friends. His punishment was never to be able to sate his appetite. He hung from a tree like one of its fruit, and all about him hung a myriad of other kinds of fruit, none of which he could ever grasp, although they were always within his reach. Below him was a pool of water which would sometimes well up within reach, but whenever he scooped the water into his hand, it would all drain away before he could bring it to his lips.2 His punishment for giving into his appetite to take the best food of all is to suffer the fate of not being able to taste any food whatever.

In the tale of Philemon and Bacis the poet describes a transformation of man to oak similar to our waiką:

Old Baucis look'd where old Philemon stood,
And saw his lengthen'd arms a sprouting wood:
New roots their fasten'd feet begin to bind,
Their bodies stiffen in a rising rind:
Then, ere the bark above their shoulders grew,
They give, and take at once their last adieu.
At once, Farewell, o faithful spouse, they said;
At once th' incroaching rinds their closing lips invade.3

Greek mythology has many arboreal metamorphoses, and the parallels could be multiplied many fold.

Links: Tree Spirits, Wood Spirits.

Stories: mentioning walnut trees: River Child and the Waterspirit of Devil's Lake, Mijistéga’s Powwow Magic and How He Won the Trader's Store; mentioning trees or Tree Spirits: The Creation of the World, The Twins Retrieve Red Star's Head, The Children of the Sun, Visit of the Wood Spirit, The Man Who Lost His Children to a Wood Spirit, The Boy who would be Immortal, The Man Who Lost His Children to a Wood Spirit, The Commandments of Earthmaker, The Old Woman and the Maple Tree Spirit, The Oak Tree and the Man Who was Blessed by the Heroka, The Pointing Man, The Abduction and Rescue of Trickster, The Baldness of the Buzzard, Trickster Eats the Laxative Bulb, Trickster Loses His Meal, The Journey to Spiritland (v. 2), Thunderbird Clan Origin Myth, Waruǧábᵉra, The Chief of the Heroka, The Red Man, The Shell Anklets Origin Myth, The Annihilation of the Hocągara I, Baldheaded Warclub Origin Myth, The Blessing of the Bow, Pete Dupeé and the Ghosts, The Spirit of Gambling, Peace of Mind Regained, The Stench-Earth Medicine Origin Myth, The Necessity for Death, The Story of the Medicine Rite.

Themes: a person's body turns into a plant: Fourth Universe (white flower), White Flower (white flower), The Boy who would be Immortal (tree), Aracgéga's Blessings (inverse: log > human), cf. The Wild Rose, Deer Clan Origin Myth (v. 2). a person obsessively craves for himself what a tree possesses, and as a consequence is transformed into a tree: The Boy who would be Immortal.


1 "Tale of the Woman who became a Walnut," in Paul Radin, Winnebago Notebooks, Winnebago III, #11a, Freeman #3892 (Philadelphia: American Philosophical Society) pp. 70-72 (140a -140 b).

2 Diodorus Siculus 4.74.3; Plato, Cratylus 28; Lucian, Dialogues of the Dead 17; Homer, Odyssey 11.582-592; Ovid, Metamorphoses 4.456; Pindar, Olympian Odes 1.60; Apollodorus, Epitome 2.1; Hyginus, Fabulæ 82.

3 Ovid, Metamorphoses 8.714-720.